What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Daylight Saving Time (DST)?



What is Daylight Saving Time (DST)?


Daylight Saving Time (DST), or summertime as it’s termed in the United Kingdom, refers to the period of time – in the spring and throughout the summer months – whereby the clocks are turned forward by one hour.


For the remainder of the year, referred to as Standard Time, the clocks are returned to “normal.” Meaning, we turn the clocks back one hour.


DST occurs in the U.K. and in many countries around the world – 70 in all.


In the U.S., almost every state observes DST, with exception to Arizona (Navajo in Arizona do observe DST), Hawaii, and various U.S. overseas territories.


With so many countries and so many U.S. states doing it – playing around with the clocks twice annually – there have to be benefits.


What are those benefits? And what, if any, are the disadvantages of observing DST?




Advantages of Daylight Saving Time


1  The evenings are lighter for longer

For most, because the evenings are longer, it’s better.


There’s more time for outdoor recreational activities.


It has been reported that with more sunshine – with more daylight – people are happier overall.



2  The economy benefits

DST has a positive impact on hospitality and tourism, as well as on retail sales.


It has been estimated that in the U.K., if DST was to remain year-round, it would pump approximately $5.6 billion (yes, that’s U.S. dollars) more into the economy because of additional tourism.



3  There’s one additional hour of sleep

When the clocks “fall” back, when the hour of 2 am strikes, the clock, in fact, goes back to 1 am.


In essence, in this way, we enjoy an extra hour in bed (if staying in bed is your thing).



4  Roads become safer 

During dawn and during dusk, because of decreased visibility, on the roads, there’s an increased risk of accidents occurring.


During the DST months, the sun sets later than otherwise, so there are far less road-related accidents.


Research has demonstrated that if DST were to be adopted throughout the entire year, the number of fatalities of vehicle occupants in the U.S. would depreciate by 3 percent, while the number of pedestrian fatalities would lower by 13 percent.



5  Reduction in crime

During DST, there are less crimes committed.




Because, with more light, it’s easier to be seen and also identified.


A study conducted by the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research found that during DST, robbery rates were reduced by 51 percent, crimes involving murder reduced by 48 percent, and crimes involving rape reduced by 56 percent.


This research was conducted to ascertain what impact additional street lighting would have on crime. After additional lighting was installed, some $558 million, in terms of social cost, was saved.



6  People are more active

More people become active in outdoor recreational activities during DST. Conversely, the amount of time spent watching TV greatly decreases.


In turn, an approximation has been made by the University of Washington that 10 percent more calories are burned, and health, overall, improves.






Disadvantages of Daylight Saving Time


1  Lost hour of sleep causes health-related problems

When there’s a lost hour of sleep due to the clock changing from DST to Standard, there are a variety of associated health issues.


Following on from the time shift, for example, the number of people who suffer cluster headaches rises.


In the days following on from a change in time, the number of strokes also rises.


The number of heart attacks rise sharply, too.


The number of miscarriages increases by almost 9 percent.


The number of suicides increase.


And, the number of workplace injuries, likewise, rises.



2  Number of accidents increase

While the number of road-related accidents decrease during DST, when the clocks change, there’s a rise in the number of road accidents.


The largest rise in road accidents is in the springtime. This is likely related to the lost hour of sleep.


Nevertheless, the fall-time clock change also sees a rise in car accidents.



3  It costs us money to switch the clocks

There’s financial loss when the clocks change. This financial loss is known as “opportunity cost.”


In the U.S., the cost involved in merely physically adjusting clocks costs approximately $2 billion annually.


This loss occurs because it takes a person an average of around 10 minutes to change the clock.


On top of this, there are other costs of altering the clock, too. Those costs amount to approximately $4 million in the U.S. annually.


This $4 million comes from the costs involved with vehicle accidents, from the costs involved with the rise in health problems, as stated above, and from the cost involved with decreased productivity.


One study found that, in general, employees prefer to do less work (20 percent of their work time is spent “cyberloafing” – non-work-related activities) in the spring just after the clocks change.



4  Depression

When it gets dark early, it causes “wintertime blues.”


For most, early darkness is merely a frustration. But for some, there are definitive health consequences involved. It’s called seasonal affective disorder, or SAD.


SAD is like “normal” depression. When you suffer from SAD you tend to have less energy, you feel moody, you may have alterations in appetite.


Nevertheless, SAD only emerges when people are not exposed to enough sunlight.


Some people even become suicidal when they suffer from SAD.


If DST is maintained year-round, SAD would be far less of a problem.



5  When the clocks change there’s less spending

From a study that was undertaken by the JP Morgan Chase Institute, it was found that there’s a significant drop in spending in the U.S. when the clocks change.


The drop in spending, depending on where you reside, ranged between 2.2 percent and 4.9 percent.


It’s a drop that persists for weeks, and for some people, a few months.



6  When the clocks change there’s an impact on sleep and circadian rhythms 

While we do get one “free” hour of sleep when the clocks are turned back, this “free” hour does little to offset the amount of sleep deficit that the majority of U.S. residents suffer from.


The hour missed in springtime is not made up for by the hour gained during fall.


Eight hours of sleep are recommended, but in the U.S., the average night of sleep consists of only 6.8 hours.


With a lack of sleep, it causes a decrease in mental alertness, it causes impairment to memory and cognitive function, and it causes an increase in the risk of suffering from numerous medical-related issues, including heart attacks, high blood pressure, strokes, heart failure and also obesity.


Additionally, the adjustment to time impacts circadian rhythms.


Circadian rhythms help to manage sleep, hormones, and also hunger.


The imbalance may take weeks or even months before it is corrected. It’s somewhat similar to jet lag, though jet lag usually only persists for a few days at a time.


Image by Pexels from Pixabay